Group Discussion Contest - 30

[HELP]

Today's Topic :



Multinational Companies: Are they devils in disguise?Edited by: HELP

[Tan]

I dont think that multinational companies are devils in disguise.
But there might be lot of pressure to complete a project.
sometimes we have to work day and night to complete it forgetting our family life.And there will b a huge compitition at work.
if we consider these reasons very tough then yes its devil in disguise.

[innovia]

No. they are not.


They bring in the new technology. Also helps to maximise the resourse utilisation. Think the number of options both in job market and in productsthey brings.Yeah..they do create more compitition, but thats what creates option!

[sowmya571]

hello






Multinational Companies: Are they devils in disguise?



Put it this way People



ARE INVESTMENTS MADE IN INDIA BY MULTINATIONALS ARE WORTH FOR INDIA OR NOT

[sowmya571]

hello



Yes the Investments made By MNC's are really worth



ADVANTAGES



1 LOTS OF EMPLOYEEMNT OPTIONS

2 GUD VALUE TO INDIA

3 SCOPE OF IMPROVEMENT

4 THEY INVEST IN INDIA, THOSE MONEY CAN BE UTILIZED TO MANY USEFUL THINGS



DISADVANTAGES:

1 IN INDIA WE GET CHEAP LABOUR

2 MANY RESOURCES AND TECHNOLOGY WILL BE UTILIZED BY FORIEGNERS





So there are benifits as well as disadvantages .. here



bye



sowmya

[mohanraai]

Well,
no, they are not giving any pressure. bcz of our wrong estimation only cause this much pressure. Our Team MAnager giving wrong study of project estimation, this will leads to work in nights and all.

They will give lot of oppurtunities to us.
but even though most values also add to our nation and more generation also adding. we can say they compensate our financial condition evenly.
if they didn't come to india then, india will slave to many countries.

so they gave more support to us.

thanks and regards,
Mohanraj.M

[Tan]

yes there should be right way to guide a project if not unneccessary pressure on the employees.

[Rena]

Hi,


Surely investment made by MNC in INDIA is useful for India.We should be proud on ourselves that they r ready to invest on us.Still they get the required thing from us,they r ready to invest.The major problem in India is unemployment.But their investment paves the way to the eradication of this problem.After the placement in the company we should make the company as a team.We should not think that they r foreigners to us and they should not think that we r foreigners to them.When we enter the company we should think the deveopment of the company and we should also have in mind that all r one.They r giving recognition to indians.The stress is not only in MNC's.It is also in local companies.


SO the investment in india is really worth.

[satyadev]

No, they are not Devils in Disguise,
Where there is a source of wealth every one move to utilise utmost resources. (as ANTS will move to Sugar.....) As the MNCs are Investing Alot In India, It is because of the More Intellectuals are there in India, For these they Provide so many facilities to employees
In the other way
Yes one of us already specified It is becuse of the Improper planning only they will put Presure On the Employees.
And one more thing they can get their work be finished very cheaply (it regards payment of an employee) and Quickly

[meera]

No i don't think so.These MNC's make the country economically strong.Many multinational companies were ready to investin india.This reduces the unemployment problem and also it will bring focus of other countries towards india.


Disadv


Even though high salary is provided the pressure given by the company is more.


Indians work in MNC's as low cost employee when compared to US.

[ari_laxmi]

yes i also agree MNC r not devil in disguise,MNC reduces the problem of unemployment .

[keerthi]

Hi all


I think advantages are more here.Since india is still developing Investments made by MNC's plays a moajor role in our development.


Though there are some disadvantages like we get less salary for more work when compared to the foriegn pay scales.And our intellectual property is used by the foreigners.


But they play a very important role now.As we are poor compared to developed states there is no other go ,we need to work for even less pay .

[Vision]

But here the main problem with this globalisation is ..





people will go crazy about MNC (not only software & hardware but
also there are many food , health , Machines etc etc ) products
.. May be because of the quality & cost. If the product quality
is good & cost is less than indian based products then 100s of
indian based companies need to shutdown their business I think this is also one reason few ppl are not supporting globalisation
Edited by: Njoy

[Priya Narayanan]

Hi i think MNC are not devils in disguise.As India is developing
country it helps us to grow in wealth. And also unemployment have been
reduced because of MNC. Eventhough some may feel work load in MNC's are
more but the salary is high.So i conclude that MNC's are not devils in
disguise.[img]smileys/smiley1.gif[/img]

[faraz]

[img]smileys/smiley5.gif[/img]I believe mnc's aredefinitely devils in disguise.Although there are huge benefits for the country as a whole but if you look at a holistic perspective your opinion will differ!!!You maybe working in an MNC but i am not criticising it,just trying to bring to fore the realisticviewpoint.These mnc's hire large amount of talented youth that work like dogs all through the day.Thats what american mentality is WORK ,WORK AND WORK.They hardly get the time to think of country or other matters.Okay they give you money and make huge investments to country bringing up the economy but at what cost?????????????Firstly they alienate us from the family indirectly affecting family ties.The youth get good pocket money and they indulge in their pleasures with total disregard to their elders.The opinions of the youth and their mentality is changed and they think totally the western way.So,MNC's ultimately are culture vultures and are penetrating into the indian family system and thereby making kids more independent at a very young age.This have broad future implications and to what extent this may cause concern to us time will tell.Finally i want to conclude that mnc's are devils in disguise and in other words can be called as a NECESSARY EVIL!!!(like friction[img]smileys/smiley5.gif[/img])